The Logic of Vegetarianism – Henry S Salt

The Logic of Vegetarianism

PREFACE In preparing this “Logic of Vegetarianism” for a new edition, I have carefully re-read a sheaf of press opinions which greeted the first appearance of the book some seven years ago, with the hope of profiting by any adverse criticism which might point out arguments that I had overlooked. In this, however, I have been disappointed, for, apart from a few such objections as that raised in all seriousness by the Spectator-that I had not done justice to the great problem of what would become of the Esquimaux-the only definite complaint which I can find is that the representatives of flesh-eating whom I have introduced in the dialogues are deliberately made to talk nonsense. “It is easy,” said one critic, “to confute an opponent if you have the selection of the arguments and the framing of the replies.” I ought not, perhaps, to have expected that the assurance given in my introductory chapter (p. 2) as to the authenticity of the anti-vegetarian pleadings would shield me from this charge; indeed, the Vegetarian Messenger, in a friendly review of the book, expressed doubt as to the policy of using dialogue at all, because, as it remarked, “the arguments against vegetarianism are often so silly that it looks as if the author had set up a man of straw in order to demolish him.” Yet, as the Messenger itself added, “there is not an argument against vegetarianism quoted in this volume which we have not, time after time, seen seriously brought forward by our opponents.” Surely it would be a strange thing if food reformers had to avoid any terse presentment of their adversaries’ reasoning for the very fact of its imbecility! And there is this further question. If I have failed to include in my selection the effective arguments against vegetarianism, where and what are they? Looking through those cited in the press notices, I can discover none that seem to be formidable; but rather than again be suspected of unfair suppression, let me frankly quote the following specimens of the beef-eater’s philosophy: “The proof that man should eat meat is that he always has done so, does now, and always will.” And again: “Nobody will want to make out that he (the advocate of vegetarianism) is wrong, but folk will just go on suiting themselves as before. Shelley and Thoreau, Wagner and Edward FitzGerald, were vegetarians, but, then, Wellington and Gladstone partook of the roast beef of Old England, and were none the worse.” There is a sublime simplicity about these statements which is most impressive, but I cannot think that any wrong is done to the case against vegetarianism by not including them in a discussion which purports to be a logical one. H. S. S.

Author: Henry S Salt
ISBN: 9781519720115
Pages: 86 pages
Format: PDF
Size: 28.02 Mb

More free books

  • The Influence of Water-Drinking with Meals Upon the Digestion and Utilization of Proteins, Fats and Carbohydrates – Henry Albright MattillThe Influence of Water-Drinking with Meals Upon the Digestion and Utilization of Proteins, Fats and Carbohydrates – Henry Albright Mattill Unlike some other reproductions of classic texts (1) We have not used OCR(Optical Character Recognition), as this leads to bad quality books with introduced typos. (2) In books where there are images such as portraits, maps, sketches etc We have endeavoured to keep the quality of these images, so they represent accurately the original artefact. Although occasionally there may be […]
  • Food Myths – Nicole SeniorFood Myths – Nicole Senior Even though we have access to more medical and health information than ever before, food and nutrition continually faces the challenge of misinformation and misconceptions. Do vegetarians live longer? Are thin people healthier than fat ones? Is sugar our enemy? What's better butter or margarine? Do adults need to drink milk? Is sea salt better for you than regular salt? Does detoxing […]
  • Dictionary of Carbohydrates – Peter M. CollinsDictionary of Carbohydrates – Peter M. Collins An easy-to-use reference source for all scientists working with carbohydrates, the Dictionary of Carbohydrates with CD-ROM, Second Edition builds on the success of its previous edition by providing a substantially increased number of compounds. The presentation is sharpened by a careful review of existing entries. With 24,000 compounds, it represents a much enlarged and revised new […]
  • A Common-Sense View of the Mind Cure – Laura M WestallA Common-Sense View of the Mind Cure – Laura M Westall We know that how you think affects your health. Happier people are healthier and more successful than their unhappy counterparts. Doctors routinely make tell their patients that they will fare better if they can keep up a good frame of mind. Here is a book that shows you how to use the power of positive thinking to feel better and live a fuller life. Author: Laura M Westall ISBN: […]
  • Art of Super-Realization : Initiation – Paramahansa YoganandaArt of Super-Realization : Initiation – Paramahansa Yogananda 2014 Reprint of Original 1930 Edition. Exact facsimile of the original edition, not reproduced with Optical Recognition Software. According to Yogananda, "Self-realization is the knowing - in body, mind, and soul - that we are one with the omnipresence of God; that we do not have to pray that it come to us, that we are not merely near it at all times, but that God's omnipresence is […]
  • Cathys Weightloss Diary Volume 1 (B&w) – Cathy DaviesCathys Weightloss Diary Volume 1 (B&w) – Cathy Davies was a popular website running from 2001 through to 2012 following the ups and downs (literally) of one woman's battle with weight, husband, children and life in general. Written with candour and humour it had people connecting in each week to see not only how the weightloss was going, but how Cathy's life in general was going. At times sad, often funny, it […]
  • Food Combining Made Easy : Third Edition – Herbert M. SheltonFood Combining Made Easy : Third Edition – Herbert M. Shelton Food Combining Made Easy was originally published during the 1940s. It became the leading primer for almost 60 years for anyone wanting guidance on which foods should and should not be eaten at the same meal. Shelton presents information on the processes of normal digestion and examines why combinations of acids, fats, starches, sugars, and proteins disrupt these processes. This new […]
  • Profiles in Oriental Diagnosis: Vegetarian Bride of Frankenstein v. 2 : Profiles in Oriental Diagnosis II : The Scientific Revolution – Alex JackProfiles in Oriental Diagnosis: Vegetarian Bride of Frankenstein v. 2 : Profiles in Oriental Diagnosis II : The Scientific Revolution – Alex Jack Author: Alex Jack ISBN: 9781882984305 Pages: 159 pages Format: PDF Size: 18.52 Mb

Leave a reply